Frater Barrabbas has
blogged recently about his concerns regarding
Jake Stratton-Kent's True Grimoire. The Frater has a
litany of woes with Jake's approach; greatest of which is its seemingly diabolical pact-making procedure. Jake did not invent this; its always been part of the grimoire, but somehow Frater Barrabbas is worried that Jake is promoting, what to his mind, is a dangerous and insanity producing form of goetic practice.
Jake draws from afro-diasporic religion and magic to inform his spirit-friendly approach, which is more or less outlined by his True Grimoire. Its a valid approach because the grimoire itself has seen widespread use throughout the diaspora. Yet Frater Barrabbas feels that this is faulty model to adapt, stating:
"Unsanctioned practices would be to seek domination, retribution, vengeance, to cause sickness and death in targeted victims, to gain assistance from the unhallowed dead and their demi-god controllers or assistance from evil spirits. These unsanctioned practices would require the help of a specialist who would perform such rites in private. One could easily categorize the evocation of goetic demons in this class of unsanctioned practices, whether of Umbanda, Palo Mayombe or Voudoun Bokor. Unsanctioned practices such as these are often tolerated due to the abject fear of such specialists or their occasional discrete use by clients. Despite the obvious associated cultural ambiguities, these practices would be considered evil and outlawed by the greater public. Some practitioners of these unsanctioned arts, whether real or imagined, have been persecuted and murdered by angry outraged members of their community. Like the folkloric theme of the classic witch known worldwide, such practitioners have always been considered outside the law and prime suspects when things in a community go awry. Is this a useful model for a modern goetic magician to follow? I greatly doubt it."
It is with this statement that I must take exception. The notion that all forms of harsh magic (domination, revenge and crossing) are naturally evil and therefor relegate its user to the fringe of the socially 'sanctioned' or 'legitimate' practices of afro-diasporic religion is patently false. Its also a view typical of the biases and assumptions that western occultists with their attendant dualisms of good and evil, black and white; bring with their, regrettably, colonial gaze. Its also very simply
misinformed about the basic context of afro-diasporic magic.
Most respected community serving priests of Umbanda, Quimbanda, Palo and Vodou are just as likely if not
more likely to use harsh magic, and hot or so-called 'evil' spirits for legitimate, punitive and destructive magical ends. It's all about providing justice and power to people who, historically, have had none - due to enslavement, poverty and oppression. Moreover destructive works can and are performed just as frequently with 'cooler' spirits and
saints than with their hotter counterparts in these cultures. Similarly, if we investigate the Quimbanda spirit hierarchy we find spirits that are master healers, spirits that are concerned with the welfare of children, spirits that help cure alcoholism and host of other benign functions. All these spirits have an almost one for one syncretism with demons of Grimoirium Verum. Its not the use of black magic or hot spirits that makes one a witch (and I use that term in its true sense) it is ones
motivation for using said 'black' magical technology. If your intentions are evil, pernicious and harmful to your community then you are understood to be an evil influence and you will most likely be removed by use of similar magic. One word; justice.
In my opinion the Frater is setting up a false dichotomy with his argument; one which reduces complex social and magical systems with its bourgeois assumptions.
Having said that, Frater Barrabbas has got a few valid points regarding safety and I think these are rooted in a genuine concern. When entering into a relationship with ANY spirit we need to be careful; we need to have experience and we need some sort of spiritual support system for when things go wrong. Because things
do go wrong. Also the Frater's concern for using angels to balance demons is more or less valid from an ATR perspective - because in these traditions cooler spirits and saints are often used to soothe and balance hotter, more feral, types of spirits. This sort of backup is something that I am personally taking into account with my work with the Verum by working with the saints and ancestors as balancing agents to the Verum spirits (as is sometimes done in Quimbanda).
We obviously should not be cavalier about entering into relationships with spirits of any sort, and certainly not those of the True Grimoire. I dont believe that Jake is promoting a cavalier way of working though; simply one that has worked for him and one that he believes has positive potential. The pact system has always been part of the Grimoirium Verum and the grimoire has been available on the internet in various forms for the longest time - so its not like he is opening a pandoras box as the Frater seems to suggest. What's more; the pact mechanism is not of the same stripe as the faustian sort that populates modern imagination. No soul selling, no terms and conditions or any such thing - its merely a evocatory device and one which is traceable back to ancient pre-christian goetic forms at that. There are a few people around, both on the Verum yahoo group and elsewhere, whom have worked the Verum system and have not been eaten alive or gone barmy yet. I have heard equally irrational claims that all operators of Enochian magic go nuts or end up dead and yet lately everyone seems to be practicing that system with no ill effect. I am sure there are other examples.
Noone is saying that Grimoirium Verum based goetic magic is
safe or cuddly; but then again no spirit based magic is. Jake did put a blood red skull on the cover, after all...
Use at your own risk.